Babista.com Domain Name Dispute Ruling Rejects Defendant's Reverse Domain Name Hijacking!

Industry Information 22 Jul 2024 11:51:36 AM By:DN editor
Abstract:

In a dispute over the domain name Babista.com, the Complainant claimed rights to the trademark “BABISTA” and accused Respondent PTB Media Ltd of registering and using the domain name in bad faith. However, after reviewing the evidence,

The Complainant, a German company, Venderstorm Ventures GmbH & Co. KG, has lost a UDRP decision on the Babista.com domain name.

In a dispute over the Babista.com domain name, the Complainant claimed rights to the trademark “BABISTA” and accused Respondent PTB Media Ltd of registering and using the domain name in bad faith. However, after reviewing the evidence, three Panelists ruled that the Complainant had failed to prove its allegations.

Background of the Case

The Complainants alleged that they are men's apparel companies that own a number of trademarks and domain names associated with the term “BABISTA”. They contend that the Respondent registered the domain name Babista.com and used it for pay-per-click links in bad faith and in an attempt to derive financial benefit from their trademarks.

The defendants argued

Respondent PTB Media Ltd, a Hong Kong-based domain name investor, asserts that they were unaware of the existence of the Complainant's trademark when they registered the Babista.com domain name. They claim that the domain name registration was based on their portfolio strategy and was registered in October 2005 along with a number of domain names ending in “-ista”, including the “.com” domain name, which has commercial potential.

The Ruling

The Panelists have reviewed the arguments and submissions of both parties and note the Complainant's deficiencies in its submission of evidence. Although the Babista.com domain name is identical to the Complainant's mark, the Panel did not find sufficient evidence to show that the Respondent knew or should have known of the Complainant's existence at the time of registration.

Accordingly, the Panel finds:

1. failed to prove identity or confusing similarity: the Babista.com domain name is identical to the BABISTA trademark owned by the Complainant, but does not satisfy the requirements of ownership and legitimate interest.

2. Failure to Prove Bad Faith Registration and Use: While domain name registration and use exists, there is no evidence that the Respondent acted in bad faith or in a manner detrimental to the Complainant's business under the trademark rights.

Accordingly, the Panel rules that the transfer of the Babista.com domain name to the Complainant is denied and that the Respondent's request for reverse domain name hijacking is also rejected.

This decision reflects the strict scrutiny of evidence and bad faith intent in domain name dispute resolution and emphasizes the importance of protecting fair competition and legitimate domain name investments.

Resurrecting the Enron.com domain: an alternative marketing tour of a historical legacy

Resurrecting the Enron.com domain: an alternative marketing tour of a historical legacy

Enron, the one-time energy giant, is once again in the conversation more than two decades after its collapse, but this time the focus is not on a business recovery but on the return of the domain name Enron.com. The domain name,

Industry Information 04 Dec 2024 09:43:51 AM

SEO challenges abound after domain name change - Wedding Company Insights

SEO challenges abound after domain name change - Wedding Company Insights

Many people think that exact match long tail domains “automatically” rank high on Google, but the truth may be more complex than that, and a recent experience by Ashish Mishra, founder of The Wedding Company, offers a new perspective on the

Industry Information 04 Dec 2024 09:00:29 AM

DN platform facilitates high-priced deal for rare two-letter YB.net!

DN platform facilitates high-priced deal for rare two-letter YB.net!

On November 29th, the rare two-letter domain name YB.net successfully completed a transaction on DN.com, the global premium domain name trading platform! The two-letter domain name was sold at a high price of six-figure RMB.

Industry Information 02 Dec 2024 02:27:17 PM

Why are non-.com three letter domain names a bad investment?

Why are non-.com three letter domain names a bad investment?

Assuming we choose only the first 500 keywords to combine for a three-word domain name, the number of possible combinations would be 500³ = 125 million. This is a huge number. The more domain names available on the market, the less likely

Investment 02 Dec 2024 09:04:09 AM

2024 Domain Trading Roundup: Record High Prices for Various Common Domain Names

2024 Domain Trading Roundup: Record High Prices for Various Common Domain Names

Before you know it, there is only one last month left in 2024! It's been a bright year for the domain trading market, with overall transaction volumes remaining substantial. For this reason, we've meticulously compiled a list of the top 10

Industry Information 30 Nov 2024 04:10:07 PM

.AI domain name registrations surge with 40,000 new registrations in the last two months!

.AI domain name registrations surge with 40,000 new registrations in the last two months!

Registrations for .AI domain names have grown by nearly 40,000 in the last two months, demonstrating the strong demand for this top-level domain (ccTLD) in the artificial intelligence industry. According to Anguilla's registry data,

Industry Information 30 Nov 2024 09:38:45 AM

Babista.com Domain Name Dispute Ruling Rejects Defendant's Reverse Domain Name Hijacking!